One thing becomes abundantly clear when reading any of Shakespeare's works: his plays lack stage direction and scenery, despite vividly worked-out plots and advanced characterization. Why did the environment of his plays not reflect this same complexity?
I immediately jump to answer that question with "It was another clue to Shakespeare's brilliance," meaning that he intentionally left his plays as universal as possible. Today, there exist so many varying interpretations of Shakespeare's works. From traditional to pastiche, the scenery of these countless versions differ so greatly that there is bound to be an interpretation that appeals to anyone.
The vague language pertaining to the setting was brilliant, but now I believe that brilliance to be unintentionally so. Elizabethan theatre traditionally did not place an emphasis on scenery. The expenses of putting on a play were instead diverted to fine materials for costumes. Shakespeare, it seems, was merely following the norm of his time.
But nevertheless, the ambiguity concerning how Shakespeare's environments should be constructed and detailed has been paramount in the development of different interpretations. My English class just finished reading and studying Hamlet. An integral part of our study was watching very different film renditions of the play. We watched David Tennant and Patrick Stewart in a modern-day, pastiche Hamlet. We watched traditional versions featuring Kenneth Branagh and Mel Gibson as Hamlet. And we watched a very strange modern-day version with Ethan Hawke and and Julia Stiles.
| Ethan Hawke and Julia Stiles |
| Kenneth Branagh |
| David Tennant and Patrick Stewart |
![]() |
| Mel Gibson |
The settings and scenery in each of these versions varied immensely, with different aspects of each being surprisingly effective. The blue, grey, and black color-scheme of the David Tennant version gave a serious, and rather grave feeling to the play. The traditional settings in both the Branagh and Gibson versions gave a more authentic feeling to the play. And the absurd, 90's filter put on the Hawke/Stiles version made the play hard to take seriously.
The environment a story is set in is inherently important to even the most universal of plots, as becomes abundantly clear when watching very different versions of the same story of Hamlet. It is easy, however, to take for granted that the environment and the plot are locked to one another. Environments can be changed, thus changing what one takes away from the same story. Once a version is created, though, the setting and the plot feed off of one another in what is hopefully a very beneficial relationship.
